How times change...or do they?

How times change…or do they?
When I was a teenager, I remember there were books containing the odd sexually explicit sentence or reference that my older sister referred to as the “mucky bits”. And, of course, we younger ones all wanted to get our hot little hands on said book and find out for ourselves exactly how mucky those bits were. And then, once we’d read and savored these titillating items, the whispering and giggling would begin: “Did you read that bit on page nineteen? Well, if you thought that was wicked just wait until you get to the end of chapter five. I couldn’t believe it, it actually says the guy unzips his pants, and he…ooh, I daren’t say it because if my mom found out…”
Despite the delicious chills and thrills those steamy excerpts produced in our young minds, they were never enough. We always wanted more. We wanted the excerpt to be a little longer, a little more explicit; we wanted the hero to be even better endowed physically; we wanted to know what happens next, and then what happens after that, and so on and so on.
Since then, bedroom doors have been thrown open and those filmy curtains blowing in the soft summer breeze have disappeared as readers gradually demanded more and more. Nowadays, in response to reader demand, books run the gamut from sweet to sexy to a little explicit to tell it all like it really is, including fetishes and spankings, domination and submission, gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender, as well as les ménages à trois and even orgies, and the stories are told through the medium of werewolves, dragons, witches and warlocks, faeries, space aliens, shapeshifters, vampires, ghosts, people from the past, as well as ordinary everyday people.
But despite the bigger selection of everything including the heat factor, I doubt things have changed since those days when we borrowed books in brown paper wrappers and rushed to read the few well-thumbed pages in the privacy of our bedroom or behind a locked bathroom door. There are still those readers who want more. They want more thrills, more shocks, and some want a little more kink--according to some, the kinkier the story the better it is. Readers are constantly pushing the envelope because the demand for more never stops.
So, my question is, where does it all end? Must we invent more and more bizarre worlds and strange characters with even stranger behavior and appetites? Or do we go full circle, back to the time when nice girls kept their knees and ankles covered, and had sex in the dark with all (well, almost all) their clothes on?
So come on, tell me…what do modern romance readers really want now? What would you like to see more of, less of, or are you happy with the wide choice currently available? Like everything else, romance stories go through phases--today vampires are all the rage, tomorrow it’s dragons, the next day the demand is for plain and simple Mary Jane who works in an office by day and indulges in orgies in her leisure time (I think perhaps I smell a new plot here). Do you want more series with more continuing characters, or do you prefer one-offs? Are you content with any handsome hero, be he Joe from next door or a sexy knight in shining armor, who will make you catch your breath and cause your heart to beat a little faster as you imagine it’s you he’s carrying off into the sunset for that fabulous HEA? Or does your perfect hero come with a list of requirements--he must be a vampire, he must be very tall, etc. etc. Or is it simply a case of I’ll know what I want more of when I read the blurb?
Please, let me know, I’m interested in hearing what readers want more or less of.
Christiane France
When I was a teenager, I remember there were books containing the odd sexually explicit sentence or reference that my older sister referred to as the “mucky bits”. And, of course, we younger ones all wanted to get our hot little hands on said book and find out for ourselves exactly how mucky those bits were. And then, once we’d read and savored these titillating items, the whispering and giggling would begin: “Did you read that bit on page nineteen? Well, if you thought that was wicked just wait until you get to the end of chapter five. I couldn’t believe it, it actually says the guy unzips his pants, and he…ooh, I daren’t say it because if my mom found out…”
Despite the delicious chills and thrills those steamy excerpts produced in our young minds, they were never enough. We always wanted more. We wanted the excerpt to be a little longer, a little more explicit; we wanted the hero to be even better endowed physically; we wanted to know what happens next, and then what happens after that, and so on and so on.
Since then, bedroom doors have been thrown open and those filmy curtains blowing in the soft summer breeze have disappeared as readers gradually demanded more and more. Nowadays, in response to reader demand, books run the gamut from sweet to sexy to a little explicit to tell it all like it really is, including fetishes and spankings, domination and submission, gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender, as well as les ménages à trois and even orgies, and the stories are told through the medium of werewolves, dragons, witches and warlocks, faeries, space aliens, shapeshifters, vampires, ghosts, people from the past, as well as ordinary everyday people.
But despite the bigger selection of everything including the heat factor, I doubt things have changed since those days when we borrowed books in brown paper wrappers and rushed to read the few well-thumbed pages in the privacy of our bedroom or behind a locked bathroom door. There are still those readers who want more. They want more thrills, more shocks, and some want a little more kink--according to some, the kinkier the story the better it is. Readers are constantly pushing the envelope because the demand for more never stops.
So, my question is, where does it all end? Must we invent more and more bizarre worlds and strange characters with even stranger behavior and appetites? Or do we go full circle, back to the time when nice girls kept their knees and ankles covered, and had sex in the dark with all (well, almost all) their clothes on?
So come on, tell me…what do modern romance readers really want now? What would you like to see more of, less of, or are you happy with the wide choice currently available? Like everything else, romance stories go through phases--today vampires are all the rage, tomorrow it’s dragons, the next day the demand is for plain and simple Mary Jane who works in an office by day and indulges in orgies in her leisure time (I think perhaps I smell a new plot here). Do you want more series with more continuing characters, or do you prefer one-offs? Are you content with any handsome hero, be he Joe from next door or a sexy knight in shining armor, who will make you catch your breath and cause your heart to beat a little faster as you imagine it’s you he’s carrying off into the sunset for that fabulous HEA? Or does your perfect hero come with a list of requirements--he must be a vampire, he must be very tall, etc. etc. Or is it simply a case of I’ll know what I want more of when I read the blurb?
Please, let me know, I’m interested in hearing what readers want more or less of.
Christiane France
P.S. The cover for Amorous Intentions, an anthology of four of my erotic romance stories, was designed by Trace Edward Zaber of Amber Quill Press.

11 Comments:
Great question, Christiane. I've been reading romance since the age of ten when I started with some Harlequins my mother had gotten in a bag of books from a garage sale. Then an older friend introduced me to the wonders of Judy Blume's Forever. And from then on, I've only wanted more.
That being said, people are people and what titillates one, is vanilla to another. Some of us prefer menage a trois with tentacled aliens while others prefer a singular kiss at the end of the story. People haven't changed. It's the exposure level and the tolerance for openess that has.
I remain an avid reader because of iinate sense of wanting more and it's also the reason I became a writer. Have a great day.
Melissa
Thanks, Melissa. I think you're probably right. Books come in all flavors, and so do reader tastes.
Christiane
I swear my name is not Anonymous, but that's the way it keeps showing up. Grr.....
Christiane
Sometimes I think technology just likes to mess with us.
I forgot to mention in my earlier post about the things I'd like to see more of. I love strong women, be they the kick ass warrior or a novitiate who ventures into a war torn country to help or the mother who finds a way to on after her child has died. No Sleeping Beauties, no Damsels in Distress.
Looking forward to Sabotage. I love a good war time romance and yours sounds deliciously different. Trace did a wickedly provocative job on Amorous Intentions Intentions.
Melissa
Intentions x2? Sometimes we trip ourselves up. lol
I love strong women, too, Melissa. Probably because I've always had to think for myself--my husband hates women who constantly turn to their SO and ask "What do you think I should say/do/etc.?"
In SABOTAGE, Pamela is determined to prove she's not the brainless party girl her dad fondly believes her to be.
Christiane
Chris
I like my women strong, too. Write them that way as well. I can't stand people, especially females, who allow themselves to be manipulated, and in the latest suspense novel of a big name author I actually skimmed those parts.
As for trends, I try most things that come along. I happen to enjoy lush historical romances with explicit scenes, but younger women don't seem to find them as appealing.
As the world changes, readers change. I'm not sure they really know what they want until they read it.
I think you're right, Carolina, about readers not knowing what they want until they read it. It's rather like fashion--how do you know if you'll like a style until you actually see it for sale.
Christiane
Tough question, Chris.
I guess I'll know the right hero when I see him. I knjow that's not much help, sort of like an editor's answer. I do tend to prefer non-series books in case I don't come in on the beginning. Although I have liked some series, so go with what you're burning to write and we'll love it.
Christiane,
I love that you've posed this question!
Personally, I adore the alpha hero, even those who border on cocky or egotistical, which I've been shamed for writing. (Think Scottie of Ancient History.)
I love (and write) real situations with heroes and heroines who make colossal mistakes, including "oops, he isn't my husband, and we've just had sex in public."
I've met a lot of editors who want only the HEA, only the subdued Alpha hero, only the heroine on the verge of reform and growth, but the truth of it all is that sometimes people don't grow. Sometimes things fall apart. As long as the readers are satisfied, I'm all for writing it. And Amberheat is versatile and open-minded enough to believe in us, when we do.
As for the heat level...I like it all. My ultra-Christian mother will blushingly ask me to tone it down a bit, but when I suggest she simply skip over the racy parts of my books, she ascertains, "But those are the best parts."
Go figure.
Thanks again for posting this very pertinent discussion.
Penny Dawn
www.pennydawn.com
Romance...with a Passion!
"But those are the best parts."
Love it, Penny! Absolutely love it.
Carolina Valdez - author of passions that unlock the sweet ecstasies of love
http://www.carolinavaldez.com
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home